More

    Palmer delays mask mandate vote to next week after hearing massive opposition

    AlaskaWatchman.com

    Hundreds of Palmer area residents stood in bitter cold weather outside the Palmer City Council chambers on Nov. 18 for a chance to publicly oppose a proposed citywide mask mandate.

    After hearing nearly three hours of in-person testimony the Palmer City Council proceeded to read the first 100 of more than 600 emails it received on the topic.

    Mat-Su residents stand outside the Palmer City Council Chambers on Nov. 18 to testify against a proposed citywide mask mandate.

    Due to the massive public turnout the meeting ended around 11 p.m. without the council taking any action. The meeting will continue on Wednesday, Nov. 25, at 5 p.m. At that time, the council may vote to either impose or reject the controversial idea.

    Modeled closely on Anchorage’s highly contentious mask mandate, the Palmer version would require masks in nearly all indoor and even outdoor settings. Businesses would carry the burden of enforcing the law as it requires them to remove anyone who fails to comply.

    Dozens of public comments warned the council not to adopt a heavy-handed mask mandate, which could hurt area businesses just before the holiday shopping season. Many who testified said they would simply take their business to Wasilla and elsewhere in order to avoid a government ordered mask mandate. Others said they would simply refuse to wear the face coverings.

    While a number of testifiers pointed out concerns that mask impede breathing, collect germs and in many cases completely fail to stop the spread of COVID-19, others said they choose to wear masks, but that it should be a personal choice. Only a small fraction of those testifying supported the mandate.

    Mat-Su residents flood the Palmer City Council Chambers on Nov. 18 to testify against a proposed citywide mask mandate.

    A town of only 6,300 residents, Palmer’s council meetings rarely see the kind of public turnout that descended on City Hall Nov. 18. The council chambers is a small room, which typically easily accommodates limited public participation. For the Nov. 17 meeting, however, a long line of people stretched around the sidewalk for a chance to address the topic.

    The mandate idea comes on the heels of the recent October election in which progressives picked up one seat on the Palmer City Council. Deputy Mayor Sabrena Combs won reelection and newcomer Brian Daniels defeated longtime council member Linda Combs, which gave the liberal wing a 4-3 majority over the more conservative members. Combs introduced the ordinance along with Councilwoman Jill Valerius.

    Combs is a self-proclaimed “progressive,” and her ordinance claims that the small historic farming town is in the midst of a COVID emergency that “threatens to overwhelm our health system, endangering the lives and well-being of our citizens.” Thus, it is necessary to introduce an unprecedented level of government authority unlike any the colony era community has ever experienced.

    As of Nov. 18, the entire Mat-Su Borough, with a population 108,300, had just 14 people hospitalized with COVID symptoms. That amounts to 0.01% of the population and even these patients are not necessarily hospitalized because of COVID illnesses. They merely tested positive for the virus when entering the hospital but could be there for any number of reasons. Since March, five Mat-Su residents have died while having a positive COVID test.

    According to the mask mandate ordinance, “All individuals must wear masks or face coverings over their noses and mouths when they are indoors in public settings or communal spaces outside the home, or outdoors when at a gathering or, when not at a gathering, when 6 feet of physical distancing from non-household members, (or small chosen close group) cannot be maintained.”

    No one is allowed to substitute a face shield for a mask unless they “cannot tolerate a mask due to a physical or mental disability.” This would include those who are deaf or hard of hearing.

    Additional exceptions are made for those who cannot safely wear a mask while doing things like getting their teeth cleaned or operating equipment that a mask might interfere with (think entanglement).

    A special onus will be on employers who “must make sure employees who are present in the workplace have access to and wear masks or face coverings when with others.” Additionally, business owners will be enlisted as enforcers over the general public and are required to “deny admittance to any individual who fails to comply with this order and shall require or compel removal of such individuals from the premises.”

    Palmer Deputy Mayor Sabrena Combs takes off her face mask during the Nov. 18 Palmer City Council meeting.

    The only time a business can allow a faceless customer is if the patron removes their mask to “eat, drink or briefly scratch an itch.” And fitness clubs are allowed to let people work out without a mask so long as they are doing “high intensity exercise.”

    Combs repeatedly removed her face mask at the Nov. 18 meeting to eat, but also set aside her face covering on multiple occasions without proceeding to eat or drink. If her proposed law passes, this would be a violation.

    Small children – under age two – are not required to wear masks, but there are no religious exemptions mentioned. Presenters, musicians and “others communicating to an audience” can go maskless only if they are a full 25 feet from the audience and everyone else in attendance is wearing masks.

    The ordinance does not spell out how Palmer would enforce the law, but states that “the city reserves the right to use all available enforcement options to ensure compliance.”

    TAKING ACTION

    • The meeting will continue on Wednesday, Nov. 25, at 5 p.m. when the council will proceed to read aloud roughly 500 more emails they received on the topic.
    • Click here to personally contact members of the Palmer City Council.
    Joel Davidson
    Joel Davidson
    Joel is Editor-in-Chief of the Alaska Watchman. Joel is an award winning journalist and has been reporting for over 20 years, He is a proud father of 8 children, and lives in Palmer, Alaska.

    Share this article

    Related articles

    5 Comments

    1. The problem with city counsels is that 10 people on the board think they have the right to tell the other 90 what to do. Figurativy speaking. It’s not a law. It must go down to juneo and be introduced as a bill and then voted on by the constituents to be passed. I dont understand why these assholes don’t get that. Just tell them to kiss your ass palmer!

    2. Actually, they stated public comment was closed last night. They will not accept anymore public comments on the matter, just finish reading the ones that are already received. They are gonna force this down your throat whether you like it or not. They know better than you ignorant heathen citizens because they got elected in a election no one knew was happening.

    3. Mongo is right as to this coming Wednesday. However, this coming Tuesday is regular meeting with a different agenda. So there is a public comment on General comments (not pertaining to the stated agenda item). Thus we do have an opportunity to state our case again, which I will be doing to refute false comments on hospitals being over-loaded and the fear mongering related to that.

    4. God forbid that everybody be willing to do a simple gesture such as put a mask on in the hopes that it might help their fellow citizens or themselves. So much for a patriotic duty.

    Leave a reply

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Donate

    Alaska Watchman relies on the generous support of our readers. All donations go directly to supporting and expanding our news coverage. Please consider becoming a regular supporter.

    Select a Donation Option (USD)

    Enter Donation Amount (USD)

    Donate

    $
    Personal Info

    Donation Total: $100.00

    Stay Informed

    Receive breaking stories and analysis from the Alaska Watchman directly to your inbox for free.

    No spam ever. Guaranteed.

    Latest articles

    Alaska can solve budget crisis by ending unconstitutional appropriations

    “Defunding power cost equalization would gut a lifeline for rural Alaska” was published by ADN on Nov. 10. Meera Kohler expertly laid...

    Anchorage should consider advice of 50,000 health professionals before imposing a lockdown

    On Dec. 1, many Anchorage businesses will either be forcibly closed or severely limited for the duration of 2020. This decision rests...

    Assemblywoman Allard urges Anchorage to keep fighting

    Anchorage has been through a lot this year, but her people are strong and many who have never before gotten involved have...

    Are Alaska’s Elections Clean?

    In the wake of this critical moment in history, a stolen presidential election, a nakedly exposed, billionaire-funded socialist revolution, with paid thugs...

    News tips