After spending seven hours reading aloud more than 250 letters dealing with a proposed citywide mask mandate, the Palmer City Council ended their Nov. 25 meeting just before midnight without voting on the measure. The meeting will be continued into its third day of testimony on Dec. 4 at 4 p.m. Another 250 additional letters still to be read into the record, which should take six to seven hours.

An opponent of the proposed citywide mask mandate in Palmer stands outside City Hall on Nov. 25.

While the council took no in-person testimony, area residents once again stood outside the city chambers peacefully protesting the proposed mandate. They held signs stating, “Keep Palmer Free,” “Honk for freedom,” and “No Mask MANDATE – Pro-Choice,” among many others.

The Nov. 25 meeting was a continuation of the initial Nov. 18 meeting in which the council heard three hours of in-person testimony and 50 written comments. The overwhelming number of those who testified opposed the mandate. On Nov. 25, the written comments also outweighed those favoring a mask mandate.

The idea of requiring everyone in the city to wear a mask was introduced by Deputy Mayor Sabrena Combs and Councilwoman Jill Valerius. It is modeled closely on Anchorage’s highly contentious mask mandate and requires face coverings in nearly all indoor and even outdoor settings. Businesses would carry the burden of enforcing the law as it requires them to remove anyone who fails to comply.

During the meeting, Mayor Edna DeVries was maskless while Deputy Mayor Combs and Councilman Brian Daniels wore masks. The other council members participated via Zoom.

According to the ordinance, “All individuals must wear masks or face coverings over their noses and mouths when they are indoors in public settings or communal spaces outside the home, or outdoors when at a gathering or, when not at a gathering, when 6 feet of physical distancing from non-household members, (or small chosen close group) cannot be maintained.” There are very limited exceptions for young children and those with disabilities.

Click here to support the Alaska Watchman.

Palmer mask mandate proposal still in limbo after seven-hour meeting

Joel Davidson
Joel is Editor-in-Chief of the Alaska Watchman. Joel is an award winning journalist and has been reporting for over 24 years, He is a proud father of 8 children, and lives in Palmer, Alaska.


  • Caleb Pempek says:

    Following the original November 18th mask mandate hearing that Friday on November 20th there was a toys for tots fund raiser in Klondike Mike’s bar where deputy mayor Sabrena Combs was not wearing a mask in a room packed with 80 people while she was seen giving hugs to people and not socially distancing. So here is a prime example of wanting to push a mandate that she doesn’t even follow I’m sure there are pictures floating around out there somewhere

  • Kathrine says:

    Isn’t it strange that during such a “crisis,” we can wait yet another week to implement an “emergency” measure…

  • Lawrence Wood says:

    No science or fact in support of the mandate. A Portuguese court has now rejected PCR testing, because of a recent study demonstrating up a 97% error rate–false positives. Even the CDC’s handbook on testing states that the tests will pick up other virion fragments and that the COVID-19 virus may not be the source of any symptoms. In other words, this entire issue is based upon conjecture, not science.