By AlaskaWatchman.com

This is not political rhetoric. It is historical fact. On April 22, 2025, radio host Mike Porcaro interviewed State Sen. Shelley Hughes and casually remarked that this year’s Alaska legislative session was a “waste of time.” What he may not have realized, or perhaps what he’s been echoing subconsciously since 2015, is that every session since then has not only been a waste of time, but an incremental betrayal of Alaska’s constitutional self-governance.

It began under Governor Bill Walker, who, with the help of a complicit legislature, permanently damaged Alaska’s once world-renowned Permanent Fund Dividend program. That single act cracked the trust between the people and their government, and invited years of bloated bureaucratic overreach, fiscal sabotage and erosion of local control.

This is not a partisan lament. It’s a decade-long timeline of dismantled sovereignty.

Alaskans must now ask themselves a simple question: Was Alaska better off then or now?

Since 2015, Alaska’s government has not only failed to protect its citizens from bureaucratic bloat and fiscal dependency, but it has also actively dismantled the pillars of state sovereignty. From the assault on the Alaska Permanent Fund Dividend to the assumption of unfunded federal trust responsibilities, the State of Alaska has institutionalized dependence, diluted accountability and weakened local governance.

2015 – The Betrayal Begins

Governor Bill Walker unilaterally expanded Medicaid without legislative approval, shackling Alaska to long-term federal obligations with only short-term federal incentives. That same year, the Alaska Permanent Fund Dividend was effectively raided to cover bloated state budgets, marking the beginning of the end for what had been a world-leading model of citizen wealth-sharing. This paved the way for unsustainable obligations and shredded the social contract between state and citizen.

2016 – Codifying Dependency

Instead of reversing Walker’s executive overreach, the Alaska State Legislature allowed the PFD cap to become routine policy. The judiciary refused to check the executive, ruling that the legislature had the power to re-appropriate the dividend. Alaska began a new normal: permanent emergency budgeting and reactive policymaking. Bureaucracy bloated while citizen payouts shrank.

2017 – Federalization Accelerates

Alaska’s Department of Health and Social Services began absorbing increasing responsibilities from federal agencies under the guise of “partnership,” especially regarding Alaska Native healthcare systems. No additional resources, personnel, or reform authority were granted. This was not empowerment. It was quiet colonization through cost-shifting.

2018 – Bureaucracy Solidifies

The administrative state grew increasingly insulated. Education and welfare agencies prioritized compliance with federal mandates over local outcomes. Public trust in Juneau continued to erode, while watchdogs, including the Alaska Public Offices Commission (APOC), failed to adequately police the growing influence of public-sector unions and special interest PACs and, in some opinions, became a political weapon.

2019 – The Dunleavy Delay

Governor Mike Dunleavy ran on a platform of fiscal sanity but quickly caved to legislative resistance. Attempts to restore the full PFD were stonewalled. A golden opportunity to shrink government, audit Medicaid, and reform welfare was squandered. By mid-year, the “Red Pen” campaign fizzled, and the administrative state emerged stronger.

2020 – COVID as Catalyst

The pandemic expanded the welfare and healthcare bureaucracies at breakneck speed. One in three Alaskans were placed on Medicaid. Federal money flowed like a river, but oversight and reform dried up. Emergency measures embedded long-term dependencies, accelerating Alaska’s slide into a managed welfare state.

2021 – Education Captured

Despite record spending per student, Alaska’s education system ranked among the worst in the nation. Attempts to pass education reform or expand school choice failed. Teachers’ unions tightened their grip, and the Department of Education shifted from teaching academics to managing bureaucratic equity mandates and federal compliance.

2022 – RCV & Jungle Primaries: The Electoral Coup

Ballot Measure 2, passed under the guise of “transparency,” institutionalized Ranked Choice Voting (RCV) and jungle primaries. This electoral scheme eliminated party primaries and distorted voter intent, further removing electoral control from local communities. Public-sector unions and dark money groups adapted quickly, gaming the new system to entrench incumbents and dilute conservative representation.

2023 – The Rise of the Welfare-Industrial Complex

Alaska’s welfare system became a self-sustaining industry. Grants, consultants, and nonprofits grew fat off human suffering. Bureaucrats chased federal compliance metrics, not outcomes. Medicaid fraud remained unchecked. Anchorage led the way in building a homelessness industry, where tents became leverage for taxpayer-funded NGOs.

2024 – Judicial Complicity and Bureaucratic Capture

The courts failed to curb the explosion of state overreach. The Office of Children’s Services remained under federal scrutiny. Alaska’s judiciary allowed the permanent realignment of responsibility for tribal health and welfare without constitutional review. State courts routinely ruled against citizen lawsuits demanding accountability.

2025 – The Tipping Point

Now, in 2025, Alaska finds itself managing federal trust obligations with no funding, beholden to a welfare system that is unaffordable, and trapped in an electoral process (RCV) that undermines the voice of its people. This year’s legislative session, described as a “waste of time” even by sympathetic media, continues the march toward technocratic rule and away from representative democracy.

The legislative low point was House Bill 69, which sought to tie public school funding to automatic annual inflationary increases. It passed both chambers of the legislature but was vetoed by Governor Dunleavy only for that veto to be sustained by the very same legislature. It was a political theater of incompetence. On its face, the bill would have permanently baked in higher spending formulas without accountability or performance outcomes. At its core, it was a payoff to entrenched education unions and a surrender to bureaucratic inertia.

Alaska is not self-governing today. It is a managed dependency, operating at the whims of federal mandates and internal actors whose interests are not aligned with the people they claim to serve.

Conclusion: The Hard Road Back to Sovereignty

Alaska has not been developing. It has been devolving and not by accident. Each legislative session since 2015 has compounded the damage, steadily weakening the state’s autonomy, undermining representative governance, and embedding bureaucratic interests where citizen interests once prevailed. We are not managing a state anymore. We are managing the illusion of one, where real power has slipped quietly into the hands of unelected administrators, federally aligned consultants, and ideologically captured institutions.

Through reckless Medicaid expansion, the theft of the Alaska Permanent Fund Dividend, the adoption of Ranked Choice Voting (RCV), the explosive growth of the welfare-industrial complex, and the quiet assumption of federal trust responsibilities without funding or oversight, Alaska is being recolonized through regulation and technocracy, not by a foreign power, but by its own government acting as a proxy for outside interests.

Reclaiming Alaska’s sovereignty is possible, but it will not be easy.

The road back will be painful, politically costly, and fiercely resisted by those who profit from the status quo, especially the public sector unions. This is not a simple policy correction; it is a systemic extraction mission.

It will require:

  • Repealing RCV and restoring transparent, accountable elections that reflect the will of the people not the will of nonprofits and lobbyists hiding behind PACs.
  • Ending Medicaid expansion and implementing sweeping audits of the entire healthcare bureaucracy forcing a shift away from paper-pushing and fraud-ridden cost centers back toward patient-centered, outcome-driven care.
  • Restoring the full Permanent Fund Dividend (PFD) as a matter of moral obligation and economic principle ensuring Alaskans, not the government, benefit from their state’s natural wealth.
  • Dismantling bureaucratic fiefdoms, consolidating overlapping agencies, and decentralizing state control and returning decision-making to boroughs, communities, and individuals who understand their needs far better than anyone in Juneau or Washington ever could.

Let me be clear: there is no shortcut to transforming this bloated, tangled, self-serving machine of a government into a lean, disciplined, citizen-first institution. It will require confronting entrenched unions, repealing bad laws, rewriting outdated statutes, breaking long-standing contracts, and most of all, telling the truth about how far we’ve fallen.

It will take leaders willing to be hated in the moment to be remembered in history.

It will take citizens willing to educate themselves, vote with intention, and resist the seductive promises of bureaucratic handouts in favor of long-term liberty.

Alaska is not self-governing today. It is a managed dependency, operating at the whims of federal mandates and internal actors whose interests are not aligned with the people they claim to serve.

But it doesn’t have to stay that way.

The moment we stop pretending this is acceptable and start acting like self-governing citizens again is the moment we begin Taking Back Alaska.

The views expressed here are those of the author.

Click here to support the Alaska Watchman.

OPINION: A decade of ‘incremental betrayal’ gutted Alaska’s constitutional self-governance

Michael Tavoliero
Michael Tavoliero resides in Eagle River, where he remains actively engaged in local politics.


23 Comments

  • Pissed Off Papa says:

    Excellent description of where we are, how we got here and how to proceed. I hope this becomes a call to action.

  • M.John says:

    A sad, painfully accurate description. Bill Walker had to run as an independent, because he was too far left for the democrats. He was, and probably still is owned by the CCP. He should be in jail.

  • Davesmaxwell says:

    dunleavy also should be in jail for his covid death squad he and zinc forced on Alaskans!!!!

  • Rod Smith says:

    Michael, as “Pissed Off Papa” wrote, you gave us a plan to proceed.
    I for one had no idea it was THIS bad. Unfortunately, due to the sinful nature of humans, it appears that the only way to keep government in check is to starve it. Period. Returning the PDF to the people is a great place to start.
    Proverbs (30.15, 16) truly said “The horseleach hath two daughters, crying, Give, give. There are three things that are never satisfied, yea, four things say not, It is enough: the grave; and the barren womb; the earth that is not filled with water; and the fire that saith not, It is enough.”
    Government is fire — never enough. Powered by the grave via sin.

  • Dee Cee says:

    Voting with intention would be nice. But first, how about voting at all? 17% turnout in Anchorage’s last election. Incumbents won the day. Breathtaking apathy rules the populace. I don’t see it changing any time soon.

    • Tamra Nygaard says:

      I doubt anyone can save Anchorage. It is full of Californicators and inbred with progressives who are progressing they know not where. I was born and raised there, loved it, but you couldn’t pay me to live there now. They have trashed the place, and doing their best to see it completely dead and buried. Voting there is a waste of time because the proggies count the votes, so nothing will change until it collapses under its own weight.

  • Davesmaxwell says:

    FIRE DUNLEAVY

  • Manny Mullen says:

    Michael, you seem to be channeling Joe Vogler.

    • Tamra Nygaard says:

      Who are you channeling? You have yet to propose anything constructive but you sure know how to whine and moan about other folks.

  • Deborah Brollini says:

    I feel compelled to comment because comments made about the Alaska Tribal Health System are false. There are these things called treaties. The federal government has never kept its promises to Alaska or Alaska Native people.

    • Southeastseventysix says:

      The treaties probably should have been between Russia and the natives. The USA purchased AK from Russia so why would we need a treaty with the more recent inhabitants of AK than the light skinned folks? I for one am growing weary of handouts for ANY groups of people other than the elderly, disabled, disabled veterans, and widows.

      • Reggie Taylor says:

        “………The treaties probably should have been between Russia and the natives……….”
        Look how well that worked for the Ukrainians.

  • Joe Nutz says:

    Interesting points you’ve made.
    How do we fix it? Can we?
    Bread and circus rules our day.
    That’s ok! Remember, everything in history has been solved peacefully! especially tyrants! Just ask nicely enough! Vote harder tehe!

  • Shelia says:

    Great article. However, you did forget to mention the action led by Scott Kendall, Walker’s former Chief of Staff, to recall Dunleavy in the first weeks after he was elected and started to serve. You also forgot to mention the austere budget he put forth that was quickly hammered to death by the legislature and the recall. Then there was the action by the State Supreme Court to strip the governor of the line-item veto power. Also remember that the lawyers group has the sole authority for “recommending” the succeeding judges to the governor. Dunleavy attempted to go around that, but was thwarted by the law. The fact that after 6 years of struggle he is still fighting for accountability with the union-beholden legislature is amazing. Oh, I almost forget – the governor also tried to get the transgender teachings out of the first four grades but had zero support, while the trans community showed up in Juneau en mass. Dunleavy has also fought every year for a larger PFD, has put in the full requirement, only to have the legislature take its axe to that as well. And in the first year, the governor submitted three proposals to amend the State Constitution, one to have Alaskans vote on any new taxes and also one to have the PFD enshrined in the constitution so the legislature couldn’t touch it. Where was the support? There were so many opportunities, but they were all lost because conservatives sat on their hands. The failure is with all.

    • Davesmaxwell says:

      SHELIA HOW MUCH POLITICAL CAPITAL HAS YOUR GUTLESS UNCLE DUNLEAVY SPENT?
      YOUR FULL OF CRAP!!!!

    • Sally Duncan says:

      Yes it was and still is. Unless we get off the couch, grow a spine and be willing to speak for the right thing to do, we will be sitting where we are only lower in the future.

  • Mark Regan says:

    Alaska law automatically accepted the Medicaid expansion. Walker did not unilaterally expand Medicaid.

  • David Bruce Long says:

    good job Michael.

  • Casey says:

    This is a great run down on the situation. HOW it was done, and how it will be fixed is by removing the RINOs. Not only the ones in Juneau who did this over the past decade, but the ones in the Party who support them. Start w filing Rep Party Rules violations Art 7 against the legislators working w the Democrats. Next, file Art 6 charges against the Rep Party District members in their Districts. The Districts are 1,2,5,7,9,10, 23&24. Go ready the Party Rules online. If you’re a Registered Republican in any of those Districts you are eligible to file charges against the Reps AND District Party members enabling the traitors who’ve been holding this State hostage for over a decade. Don’t kid yourself, none of this would have happened if the Republican Party wasn’t infiltrated by just enough Democrats to take over Juneau. They could not have done that without the help of their Districts. The District is how you get this fixed.

  • Fed Up says:

    Nobody votes because, why? The whole election system is totally crooked and just makes us look foolish. Politicians don’t win. They are placed. We need help from the new US Administration and Dan Sullivan. He needs to approach the president with the bleak downfall looming over Alaska. Trump loves Alaska. He needs to know we are helpless unless he helps get these crooked judges off the bench and launches a full audit and investigation. Trump should abolish Rank Choice Voting nationwide in the Supreme court. He knows it damages the election process and we aren’t the only state suffering from it.

    • Davesmaxwell says:

      I completely agree and Shelia maybe you ought to copy and paste FEDUPS COMMENTS TO YOUR DELUDED BRAIN! Dunleavy should have, could have, but stupidly refuses to implement anything that cleans up the disastrous mess in his administration! DOE,HHS,DOC, etc! While our state is in a free fall, dunleavy is in DC as a special guest speaker! (who in their right minds would pay to hear him)??? WE ARE NOT BEING LED! WE ARE BEING MANAGED FOR DECLINE!
      REMOVE DUNLEAVY!!!

  • DONN LISTON says:

    Excellent overview with accurate explanation of the conditions which have exacerbated the decline we have witnessed. Unfortunately Alaska no longer has the caliber of leadership to address the magnitude of the approaching calamity.

    Elected officials cannot adequately serve the majority of Alaskans from backwater Juneau.

    Two terms of Dunleavy has been a formula for devastation.
    https://donnliston.net/2024/06/why-alaskans-deserve-to-elect-our-state-ag/