After high school and a few months of college, at 17, I served my country. I now see a phrase on my driver’s license, my VA card, when I present my military ID, and anywhere I use the military discount.
“Thank you for your service” began as a sympathetic and corrective phrase. It grew especially strong after Vietnam, when the country recognized that many returning veterans had been ignored, mistreated, or politically blamed for wars they did not personally start. In that sense, the phrase was meant to restore respect: we see you, we appreciate your sacrifice, and we will not repeat the mistake of dishonoring returning service members.
But over time, the phrase has become so common that many veterans hear it as automatic, ceremonial, or emotionally empty. Pew found that 76% of Americans reported thanking someone in the military for serving, and 92% of post-9/11 veterans said someone had thanked them after discharge. That shows how widespread the phrase became, but widespread use can also make it feel formulaic. (Pew Research Center)
The problem is not gratitude itself. The problem is shallow gratitude. Many veterans do not need strangers to perform respect with a slogan. They often prefer real curiosity, human recognition, and informed conversation. The Department of Veterans Affairs itself suggests that after thanking a veteran, people can ask questions such as: “What did you do in the military?” or “How long did you serve?” “Did anyone else in your family serve?” or “Why did you choose the service branch that you did?” (VA News)
ALASKA WATCHMAN DIRECT TO YOUR INBOX
That is a better approach because it recognizes the veteran as a person, not just a symbol. “Thank you for your service” can unintentionally reduce a veteran’s entire experience to a patriotic phrase. Asking, “What branch did you serve in?” or “What did you do in the military?” opens the door to a story. It respects the difference between Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines, Coast Guard, Space Force, National Guard, combat arms, intelligence, logistics, aviation, medical, administration, training, and countless other roles.
A fair conclusion is this: “Thank you for your service” is not wrong, but it is incomplete. Said sincerely, it still has value. Said reflexively, it becomes a social script. Veterans generally respond better when gratitude is followed by interest, listening, and respect for the complexity of military life. Some veterans welcome the phrase; others find it hollow or uncomfortable, especially when it feels disconnected from actual understanding or civic responsibility.
The views expressed here are those of the author.
10 Comments
I served as did my Dad and All my Uncles, They all said to show true gratitude VOTE for People who support the Military and Our Constitution !
Why should I thank you for fighting for the empire? There was a time when it was honorable. But now the armed forces are used like tp just like the right of us. We have criminals ruling over us. The tree of liberty is parched.
Yet.. Here you are.. Living in that “empire” and enjoying the fruits that it provides.
I’m an Army combat vet and I agree with Micah. Additionall, our unnecessary constant foreign wars have actually made America worse. Our debt has exploded, weve murdered millions, many of our best Americans died, and for what? There’s no end to the wars in sight.
Can’t disagree with this sentiment! As a whistleblower 15 years have gone by now and no one yet has shown any effort to express gratitude for exposing corruption and experiencing real life consequences for telling the truth!!! Knowing what I know now, it’s doubtful that I would do it again!
Is the phrase overused? Sure. Formulaic? A little. But I remember that it is used to express gratitude. It is a unique thank you. And, with the abrupt speed of most quick interactions, I can’t expect anything more and welcome it.
When I hear that all too familiar “Thank you for your service”; as a Vietnam Vet retiree, my response is always: Thank you for your “thank you.” I appreciate their acknowledgement; which is MUCH more than what we had received during the Vietnam conflict.
Yes, you are right on! My brother went through that discrimination but it did not control or deter him in his purpose and his choices. My nephews were two young men of strong purpose and none of that deterred them either. So for my son, my father and my other two brothers and the cousin I thought so highly of or the history in my family of my great grandfather fought in the Civil War. All buried with honor. When I hear those words of thank you, it reminds me of them and other headstones of men and women choosing their destinies and their life’s purpose and in that these men and women become what humanity honors. That honor is extended to those who are still with us, serving and are the example of purpose we aspire too. I thank them.
Sometimes You on the receiving end of a shallow compliment You just have to be the one who shows deeper gratitude and grace to someone’s perceived insincerity; kinda of like a service worker taking a Thank You from a guest who seems to only be thanking you that you are the one serving and not them.
You accept it with Grace and Humility. Military service men and women also can learn those lessons too. What’s worse not getting any acknowledgment at all if the giver is insecure it’ll be not received or that he doesn’t know what to say; so he says nothing at all.
Yes.. “Thank you for service” is an empty reply. I hear it all the time, but only a handful actually meant what they said. You could see it in their eyes and face. My eyes water a bit when I come across those that meant it. I didn’t do anything special or heroic. I did the best I could to be a part of defending this country, just as my forefathers before me.