Ketchikan Borough Mayor Rodney Dial is urging the Assembly to support his resolution calling on businesses to “refrain from discriminating against any individual by denying that person access to goods of services based upon their COVID-19 vaccination status.” His resolution will be considered at the Dec. 21 meeting. Below is Dial’s summary, which notes that people were “endowed by our Creator” with individual freedoms.


The United States of America was founded on the principles of liberty, justice, and the primacy of individual freedoms endowed by our Creator. These fundamental protections are enshrined in the United States Constitution and Bill of Rights, and are likewise explicitly protected in the Alaskan Constitution wherein it recognizes and protects some of these freedoms in Article I, Section 22 by stating: The right of the people to privacy is recognized and shall not be infringed.

The civil liberties of our citizens have continually weighed heavily on the minds of public officials…

Our community remains in the throes of an unprecedented pandemic due to the COVID-19 virus. In addressing the public health threats throughout much of 2020, our local community has, unlike many municipalities across the country, largely successfully managed the pandemic without the need to direct and prohibit citizen actions by government mandate. Instead, the greater Ketchikan community has followed the guidance of our local EOC, state mandate requirements, and CDC guidance to contain and control the spread of the virus.

This approach has featured heightened requirements for travel on commercial carriers, but has not included broad governmental mandates regarding curfew, the right to assemble, and the requirement to wear masks and other PPE. Much of the community’s success in combating the pandemic has been through recommendations, public education, and requests for citizen support for various measures designed to stem the spread of the disease. The civil liberties of our citizens have continually weighed heavily on the minds of public officials and emergency management teams.

Some communities may try to mandate vaccination as the vaccine becomes more broadly available.

With the federal regulators hurrying the processing of approvals for COVID-19 vaccine usage, we soon stand to face another challenge to find a balance between combating the pandemic and protecting the civil liberties of the citizens. Some communities may try to mandate vaccination as the vaccine becomes more broadly available. Others will limit the ability of citizens to exercise certain fundamental rights unless the citizens submit through compulsion to be vaccinated, or equally onerous, provide evidence of private information confirming they have chosen to submit to medical treatment.

Many will see these as worthy and measurably the small surrenders of fundamental constitutional rights necessary to protect public health. Many others will recognize that small sacrifices of liberties are in certain respects a trade of freedom for security, an exchange not made without full and conscious recognition of the costs to those constitutional principles we hold dear as a community and as a nation.

In facing the coming challenge posed by broad availability of the COVID-19 vaccine, the imperative of the moment will seem paramount. The fear and loss associated with what COVID-19 has brought to 2020 is never more apparent. Nevertheless, as public officials, the sponsor feels it is equally imperative to, in the course of determining ongoing public response to COVID-19, weigh in on the side of our constitutional rights. This is done by offering a reminder and an urging to merchants and service providers that decisions to require fellow citizens to surrender fundamental rights in exchange for access to essential goods and services should be disfavored by all of us who enjoy the freedoms offered in this constitutional republic. We should be able to collectively agree that the pandemic must be defeated, but that the prices we pay in order to do that must be decided in a conscious and thoughtful way.

As drafted, this resolution does not deny any entity from asking private information of a citizen or even offering incentives to provide the information voluntarily. Nor does the Resolution offer direction to or impose requirements on public institutions such as schools or workplace/employee requirements. Those are matters to be addressed by the State and Federal legislative bodies, and perhaps the courts to determine. It is the belief of the sponsor that this Resolution is necessary, timely, and the concern valid as some businesses have already indicated that they will require COVID-19 vaccination by customers utilizing their service in the future.

As elected officials it is our duty to protect the rights and freedoms of the citizens we serve and this resolution is a means to affirm that charge.


  • The meeting will be conducted online due to COVID-19 concerns. Citizens may access the live meeting via Webex; local KPU television; or live webstream at The meeting will be held through the Webex online videoconference platform. The Webex app can be installed on iPad, smart phone or computer. The WebEx Meeting Number is: 126 482 1686; Password: SocialDistance6. Citizens may provide comments to the Assembly either verbally or in writing. Submit written comments to to be read into the record. To sign up to speak during citizen comments or public hearings, call 228-6605 prior to 3 p.m. on Dec. 21.
  • Read Mayor Dial’s resolution here.

Ketchikan mayor aims to defend civil liberties of those who refuse COVID vaccine

Joel Davidson
Joel is Editor-in-Chief of the Alaska Watchman. Joel is an award winning journalist and has been reporting for over 24 years, He is a proud father of 8 children, and lives in Palmer, Alaska.


  • elizabeth s. degler says:

    The sentence ,”as elected officials it is our duty to protect the rights and freedoms of the citizens we serve; and this resolution is a means to affirm that charge.” I fully support this exercise of reason.

  • elizabeth s. degler says:

    I fully support a defense to freeman as valuable as the freeman viability. The United States Constitution colors the essence of the freeman.

  • Herb Ratcliff says:

    Have you ever heard of the small pox vaccine? It left a scar on your arm.
    Small pox was eradicated in the United States by vaccination. Many adults of today remember it well, including the Salk vaccine DPT and more. Vaccinations save lives.
    Mayor Dial, in addition to revelations, you should study history and how vaccines saved lives and perhaps enabled you to be here to profess anti-vaxer theories..
    In the recent past, students were not allowed to enter school without a “shot card”, aka vaccination certification.
    Thanks to the success of vaccinations, the last natural outbreak of smallpox in the United States occurred in 1949.
    Due to the Salk vaccine vaccination program in the early 1950’s Polio was eliminated in the United States. Perhaps you would better serve the public by encouraging vaccination against Covid-19 rather that giving credence to the anti-vaxxer crowd from both sides of the political spectrum. Covid has no political party loyalty. Direct your efforts toward supporting the health of your constituents and support business and re-opening the economy.

    • Cynthia Buchanan says:

      I get that vaccine have been wonderful. However it took 23 years to come up with the polio vaccine and I can’t find exactly how long it took to find the small pox vaccine as over the course of its find it has been modified since 1796. I have a hard time believing that in less than a year they have a vaccine. My gut says no way. To many times the first vaccines have had dire consequences. I don’t feel people should be forced into vaccinations when the outcome is I known.

      • Pat Hayes says:

        I agree there has been no time to find a cure let alone an immunization. If there is such why are people getting sick they should have the roght medicine to cure u if u have it. What cures it? Where is that answer. They really dont know

    • Herman Nelson says:

      Herb, you should also realize with the illegals pouring into the country, small pox and other diseases that were extinguished; are coming back. Those that have been vaccinated, no problems. Those that have not been, a different story. No one (except the military) has been vaccinated for small pox since 1972.
      Herb, while you are at it, could you cut the fear mongering crap out? Most of us are done with mask BS and businesses closing. I’m going to use a line from democrat pro-choicer’s- my body, my choice.

  • Ima S says: