By AlaskaWatchman.com

Editor’s note: This column was updated to clarify that X identified 200 Chinese bot accounts that were potentially manipulating legitimate online debate about AI and energy policy.

It is hard for voters to get accurate information anymore. Many traditional news sources are guilty of having a strong editorial bias, and some cross the line into dishonesty. Last week we saw three examples of how untruthful techniques are being used to shape public opinion to achieve a political objective.

The first example relates to the public narrative about AI data centers. Last Friday I published a story showing the pros and cons of building data centers on the North Slope to help fund the state budget. On the same day, X announced that a bot farm of 200,000 Chinese bot accounts were identified on the social media platform. Of these, 200 accounts were posting in a manner that could “manipulate a legitimate debate about American AI and energy policy,” X announced.

Evidently, China is seeking a technological advantage in this emerging technology and is using fake social media posts to slow its adoption in this country.

If you aren’t familiar with what a bot farm is, it is a large group of automated accounts or devices that work together to fake online activity. The bots pretend to be real people, liking posts, making comments, etc. They are used to boost traffic on a site and give the illusion that there is more interest or support for an idea than there really is. If you frequent social media and are friends with someone like Uncle_Billy_1977, whom you have never met in person, just be aware that he might not be real. He might be a bot trying to influence what political views you should have or which politicians you should support.

Politicians, social media, and mainstream media organizations are not giving you the complete truth. They are feeding you deceptive information, trying to shape your opinions to support their objectives

Anyway, Elon Musk just caught 200,000 of them, supported by the Chinese government, who were on X, pushing the narrative of how bad the AI data centers are. Musk had the accounts banned from X.

If you oppose AI data centers in Alaska, ask yourself where you got the information that made you think that way. If you don’t know the source, you might have been influenced by a bot without knowing it.

The second way the public is influenced is when politicians or the media tell outright lies to support a false narrative. This is what Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro did last week. In a press conference he held about measles deaths in his state. He said that two unvaccinated people had died from measles and implied it was because of vaccine hesitancy caused by the Trump administration and mentioned HHS Secretary Robert Kennedy by name. Shapiro’s statements were a falsehood.

The coroner for the county where this happened said this was not correct. He said that there was only one fatality that was measles-related. A newborn infant did die in a home birth from a lacerated spleen that occurred during delivery. The autopsy showed the infant tested positive for measles antibodies; however, the coroner concluded that the infant did not die from measles and that Governor Shapiro was being intentionally deceptive in saying so. One important point the coroner made is that newborns are not eligible to get the measles vaccination until they are 12 months of age. The MMR vaccination would not have saved this child, whose death was not caused by vaccine hesitancy.

When Governor Shapiro told this falsehood, he was sharing a story that fits the preconceived beliefs of the political left. This lie was more about getting Democrat support for Shapiro’s planned presidential run in 2028 than it is about promoting public safety.

The last example of liberal propaganda is when the media committed a lie of omission by not covering stories damaging to Senator Murkowski. Alaska’s little Princess has publicly opposed the SAVE America Act requiring photo ID and proof of citizenship to vote. Murkowski justified her opposition in a speech on the Senate floor about how this legislation would be a hardship for Alaskans in rural villages. Last week, independent journalist James O’Keefe traveled to Alaska to confirm the accuracy of her claims. O’Keefe was able to disprove many of the facts Murkowski cited and documented his findings on his news site.

The problem with this isn’t the falsehoods Murkowski told. The issue is that none of the mainstream media in Alaska covered O’Keefe’s story about them. This should have been big political news in Alaska, but it wasn’t covered in the Anchorage Daily News, on Alaska Public Media, KTUU, KTOO, or any other major news sources in Alaska. It was left to alternative news sites like the Alaska Watchman and a few talk radio shows to give the small amount of coverage this story received. The liberal Mainstream is trying to protect Lisa Murkowski. When they don’t cover this story, it doesn’t change the facts of the matter; it just hides them from the voters.

The upshot from all of this is to understand that in the run-up to the November election, you and every other voter in Alaska are a target of the propagandists. Politicians, social media, and mainstream media organizations are not giving you the complete truth. They are feeding you deceptive information, trying to shape your opinions to support their objectives. You might consider yourself to be a discerning individual immune to this kind of influence, but you should remember the famous words attributed to Mark Twain: “It is easier to fool a man than to convince him that he has been fooled.”

The views expressed here are those of Greg Sarber. Read more Sarber posts at his Seward’s Folly substack.

Click here to support the Alaska Watchman.

Data centers, vaccines or Murkowski’s ‘facts’: Don’t fall for political propaganda

Greg Sarber
Greg Sarber is a lifelong Alaskan who spent most of his career working in oilfields on Alaska's North Slope and in several countries overseas. He is now retired and lives with his family in Homer, Alaska. He posts regular articles on Alaskan and political issues on his Substack at sewardsfolly.substack.com.


9 Comments

  • David Eastman says:

    Greg, it’s worse than you think. In this article you are a victim (and purveyor) of pro-data center propaganda targeting conservatives. If you follow the link you shared to the Axios story about the Chinese bots you will quickly discover that it wasn’t 200,000 bots. It was 200 bots. You have unwittingly magnified that particular problem by x1000. There were 200,000 Chinese bots. A grand total of 200 of them were caught saying bad things about data centers. The propagandists for data centers (which are pumping big bucks into the propaganda sphere just like the Chinese) often conveniently hide that fact in their headlines and reporting to conservatives, leading many conservatives like yourself thinking that China was just caught pumping the Internet with 200,000 bots worth of anti-data center garbage. There is propaganda available on both sides of the AI data center debate. Conservatives need to stay as shrewd as serpents and not fall for either.

    • Greg sarber says:

      Hi David, you make a good point. However, put it another way. If somebody gave you a jar with 200,000 M&Ms, and he tells you at least 200 are poison, do you trust the remaining ones? Or do you throw them all out?

    • Micah says:

      I agree. I voted for no war, mass deportations and reindustrializing our country all in an effort to rise working class wages so young people could take the risk, get married and start a family so our country would not have a 1.6 replacement rate and there could be an American future. I never thought I would have voted for war for a foreign country, the DHS Sec in August praising a million immigrants legalized this year and mass surveillance through data centers and Flock cameras.

      What a poop show this administration has become. There really is little difference between the marxists with their open borders, dei, alphabet mafia bs and the neocons with war, surveillance and corruption. I would never vote for a D, but it will be few and far between a vote for an R again. Fool me once…. Both party’s are like the Whigs in 1850- not long for this world and good riddance.

  • Proud Alaskan says:

    You’re so right about these lame media companies. Example man gets hit by a bus, dies from covid, Not, the bus took his life. So many lies wake up people. Keep your mask on and stay six feet away.

  • Tamra Nygaard says:

    If you expect the leftist media to cover anything that might tarnish Princess Lisa’s image, you are sadly delusional.

  • Steve says:

    Evil protects it own. We see that in how the legacy media covers for, by not covering, Lisa Murkowski’s evil reign.

  • Ted Turner says:

    As usual Eastman opens his yap before he knows what he is talking about. X accounts (which is what Musk banned) can control thousands of smart phones, each one a “bot”- which is where the 200K number comes in. Eastman is a caricature of knowledge and has about the same creditibilty as the Alaska Beacon. Probably time he gets a real job somwhere.

  • David Boyle says:

    It is indeed very unfortunate that the mainstream media has failed America. That is just another step on the way to becoming a communist country–taking over the media. See “The Naked Communist” for more.

  • Bartman says:

    Read everything you can get your hands on…everything. View all TV channels and see what they have to put out. Then do some digging for information yourself and then after doing this…you make up your own mind. Get to the source!