Murkowski tries to appease liberals but ultimately backs Justice Barrett for Supreme Court

    After echoing a litany of liberal partisan objections for why she opposed seating a new U.S. Supreme Court justice weeks before a presidential election, Sen. Lisa Murkowski begrudgingly voted to confirm Justice Amy Coney Barrett to the nation’s highest court on Oct. 26. The final vote was 52-48 with Sen. Dan Sullivan also backing Barrett.

    Sen. Lisa Murkowski

    Murkowski was the center of national speculation ever since the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg died last month. At first, Murkowski said she strongly opposed seating a Supreme Court justice until after the presidential election. She argued that because the Republican-controlled Senate refused to confirm President Obama’s nominee before the 2016 election, they should also refuse to seat President Trump’s pick in 2020.

    This was the standard talking point of Senate Democrats throughout Barrett’s confirmation hearings. Scores of liberal activist groups made this argument. Planned Parenthood and other abortion rights groups went so far as to assert that Republicans were stealing Ginsburg’s seat on the Supreme Court.

    In reality Republicans operated in strict conformity with the U.S. Constitution and the rules of the U.S. Senate. They were within their constitutional rights both to deny Obama’s appointee four years ago as well as to confirm Barrett.

    Murkowski, who enjoys the support of Planned Parenthood and other liberal groups like NARAL Pro-Choice America,  played coy for weeks as national news outlets speculated about how she might vote. Meanwhile, conservative organizations like Heritage Action applied political pressure as did a number of local organizations in Alaska.

    Justice Amy Coney Barrett is sworn into office as a Supreme Court justice.

    Barrett’s opponents found it nearly impossible to attack her reputation or stellar qualifications, but Senate Democrats voiced concern that the conservative Catholic mom with seven children might rule against their side when it comes to issues like Obamacare, abortion, LGBT laws and a host of other liberal favorites. With Barrett’s confirmation the high court now enjoys a 6-3 conservative majority.

    The day before casting her vote to confirm Barrett, Murkowski took to the Senate floor where she gave a 12-minute justification for what many – on both the left and right – viewed as political waffling.

    “My record has been pretty clear, pretty consistent,” she claimed. “Some might even suggest boring in its consistency.”

    She then claimed that her recent actions in the Senate to repeatedly oppose motions granting Barrett a hearing are not inconsistent with her ultimate vote to confirm her.

    Murkowski added that the confirmation of Barrett does not “help our country become a better version of itself,” but then asserted that she was being consistent by choosing to vote for a judicial nominee when the question finally came before the entire body of the Senate for an up or down vote.

    “While I oppose the process that has led us to this point, I do not hold it against her (Barrett) as an individual who has navigated the gauntlet with grace, skill and humility,” she concluded.

    Murkowski will face reelection in 2022.

    Click here to support the Alaska Watchman.

    Share this article

    Related articles

    1 Comment

    1. Really? It really is excellent to witness anyone ultimate begin addressing this stuff, however I?m still not really certain how much I agree with you on it all. I subscribed to your rss feed though and will certainly keep following your writing and possibly down the road I may chime in once again in much more detail good work. Cheers for blogging though!

    Leave a reply

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here


    Alaska Watchman relies on the generous support of our readers. All donations go directly to supporting and expanding our news coverage. Please consider becoming a regular supporter.

    Select a Donation Option (USD)

    Enter Donation Amount (USD)


    Personal Info

    Donation Total: $100.00

    Stay Informed

    Receive breaking stories and analysis from the Alaska Watchman directly to your inbox for free.

    No spam ever. Guaranteed.

    Latest articles

    With Alaska’s chief justice to retire in 2021, judge selection process must be fixed

    Chief Justice Joel Bolger will retire from Alaska’s Supreme Court on June 30 next year, creating yet another vacancy on Alaska’s highest...

    Moving Gov. Dunleavy off the fence

    Gov. Mike Dunleavy has squandered his political capital and mandate through fits and starts. To be sure, he has faced unprecedented problems...

    Retired Lieutenant General to Alaska: Biden is coming for our guns

    With every passing day it appears more likely Joe Biden will become our next president. From the illegal vote counting, vote harvesting,...

    Alaska can solve budget crisis by ending unconstitutional appropriations

    “Defunding power cost equalization would gut a lifeline for rural Alaska” was published by ADN on Nov. 10. Meera Kohler expertly laid...

    News tips