The head of Planned Parenthood in Alaska is urging abortion activists to oppose two bills that look to shore up election integrity and reform the way Alaska selects its judges.

Sen. Mike Shower

Introduced by Republican Sen. Mike Shower, of Wasilla, SB 14 takes up the hotly debated question of how Alaska chooses and retains judges. The bill checks the powerful influence of the left-leaning Alaska Judicial Council, which currently has incredible power to nix all potential judges and provide recommendations to voters as to whether they should retain or oust sitting judges when up for retention.

Shower’s bill would remove the Judicial Council from vetting judges up for retention, giving this duty to the Commission on Judicial Conduct. More importantly, the bill does away with the absolute stranglehold the Judicial Council has to disqualify conservative minded judges from even being considered to fill a vacancy on the bench. Rather than limiting all potential nominees to those hand-picked by the seven-member Judicial Council, Shower wants to give the governor more leeway to choose someone who may not be to the Judicial Council’s liking, but who is nevertheless highly qualified to serve on the bench. Any new judge would also be subject to majority approval by the Alaska Legislature.

Conservatives have long pointed out that Alaska’s current judicial selection process is highly partisan, despite liberal claims to the contrary.

Jessica Cler, the state director for Planned Parenthood has criticized the judicial reform bill, saying it would “politicize the judicial appointment process by requiring legislative confirmation.” This is, however, the way the federal government operates. The president nominates, and the U.S. Senate confirms judges to the federal bench and U.S. Supreme Court.

Cler says such a move would empower Gov. Mike Dunleavy to choose judges based on politics rather than merit.

“One of the most important powers of the Governor is their ability to nominate judges,” Cler said in a Feb. 4 notice to abortion activists. “We should pick judges based on their legal qualifications, fairness, and experience — not politics. This is a significant and harmful change from our current system.”

Conservatives have long pointed out that Alaska’s current judicial selection process is highly partisan, despite liberal claims to the contrary. The difference is that four attorneys on the Alaska Judicial Council hold all the power to nix conservative or pro-life judges they deem unfit. Reforming the process to include the governor and State Legislature provides more transparency and accountability to the process, reform advocates argue.

Planned Parenthood is also fighting against Shower’s SB 39, which the abortion giant calls “an awful voter suppression bill.”

The measure prohibits absentee voting via facsimile, which is less secure than mail-in ballots. The bill also aims to secure the state’s voter rolls by repealing automatic voter registration when Alaskans sign up for their PFDs. Shower’s bill requires Alaskans to proactively request to be registered to vote.

Additionally, Shower’s bill ensures that all ballots deemed “spoiled” are not immediately destroyed but marked as spoiled and then sealed. The bill directs the state to preserve all ballots for 22 months, rather than only 30 days, before they are destroyed. Additionally, the destruction of ballots must be done in a single location and under direct supervision of the Division of Elections director. The bill also explicitly states that it is a crime to knowingly collect a ballot from another voter unless they are a caretaker or family member of the voter or engaged in official duties as an election official, postal worker or private commercial delivery service. It clarifies that it is a crime to “intentionally” open or tamper with a sealed ballot certificate and envelope without express authorization from the Division of Elections director.


SB 14, which deals with judge selection, is scheduled for two hearings in the Senate Judiciary Committee. The first is on Feb. 10, 1:30 p.m. (public testimony will be heard). The second is Feb. 12, 1:30 p.m. (invited testimony only). Click here to contact the members of the Judiciary Committee.

SB 39, which deals with vote security and regulations, is scheduled for two hearings in the Senate State Affairs Committee. The first is Feb. 9, 3:30 p.m. (no public testimony). The second is Feb. 11, 3:30 p.m. (invited testimony only). Click here to contact members of the State Affairs Committee.

Alaska abortion business opposes bills to reform vote security, judge selection process

Joel Davidson
Joel is Editor-in-Chief of the Alaska Watchman. Joel is an award winning journalist and has been reporting for over 24 years, He is a proud father of 8 children, and lives in Palmer, Alaska.


  • Robin Mitchell says:

    First, Marla Greenstein who has run the conduct commission for decades and has been shown in court testimony to go as far as perjury in order to protect a sitting judge needs to be forced to resign and the head of the agency needs to be an elected position.

    Before that is done, any changes will be a waste of time.

  • Ruth Ewig says:

    Our government needs to be cleaned up. The judges are running the executive and legislative branches. Who is in charge? The courts are evil with their excuse of a living constitution instead of the Rule of Law that we the citizens should be following not some judges whims. There might be 5 at most judges who honor the Rule of law. The legislative branch is not legitimate with Dominion and who knows what other machines are involved before Dominion? Our Governor need to stand up for the Rule of Law and what is right and wrong. The governor was correct to penalize the judges’ salaries for their pro-abortion stance. Dunleavy needs to be offensive no matter what. We elected him, never mind all the noise. We elect legislators to Juneau as Republicans and once in office they decide they want to be Democratic/marxists. Dunleavy needs to be offensive at all times. This is a war. Historian David Barton did a talk on Victory Channel, January 10 titled “Running to the Roar.” Watch and take notes. We have. (Fairbanks, AK)